Immich vs Google Photos comparison: the real Immich logo on indigo and the real Google Photos logo on blue, split by a VS badge

Immich vs Google Photos: Which Photo Library Should You Trust?

Short answer: pick Google Photos if you want a photo library that just works — automatic backup, the best search and editing, and zero maintenance — and you are comfortable paying for storage once the free 15 GB fills. Pick Immich if you want your photos on hardware you own, with no subscription and no company scanning your library, and you are willing to be your own IT department. The two apps do the same core job — back up your phone’s photos, organize them, and let you find any picture in seconds — but they are opposites in every way that matters. Google Photos is a managed cloud service. Immich is open-source software you run yourself. There is no single winner here: the right choice depends on whether you value convenience or control more, and this comparison tests both claims instead of repeating their marketing.

How I checked this: every price and feature claim below was re-verified against the vendors’ own pages on November 11, 2026 — Immich’s official site and GitHub releases, and Google’s Google One plans page and Photos support docs. For the hands-on test I used Immich’s official public demo instance, running v3.4.0, because this machine has under 1 GB of free RAM and Immich’s full stack needs roughly 6 GB, with 8 GB recommended — running a local server here would have proved nothing except that the machine is too small. I tested the real Immich web app on the demo’s own library of 32,948 photos and videos: smart search, face grouping, albums, and the map view. Google Photos claims rest on Google’s documentation, since testing it requires a signed-in Google account with a personal photo library. Where a claim comes from documentation rather than something I clicked through myself, I say so.

What each one actually is

Immich is a self-hosted photo and video backup application. It is open-source software under the AGPL-3.0 license, started in February 2022 by developer Alex Tran as a personal project to get Google Photos’ backup convenience without the account behind it. You install it on your own hardware — usually a small home server, a NAS, or a mini PC running Docker — and it gives you automatic mobile backup, face recognition, natural-language search, albums, partner sharing, and a map view, all computed on your own machine. It has passed 118,000 GitHub stars, and its current stable release is v3.4.0, published November 10, 2026. The v3.3.0 release before it added shared people management, birthday memories, and faster machine-learning models. There is no Immich cloud, no Immich account, and no paid tier: the server, the mobile apps, and every feature, including face recognition and smart search, are free.

Google Photos is the default photo service for most of the world. It comes with every Google account, backs up your phone’s photos automatically, and organizes them with Google’s machine learning: face groups, search that understands plain language, and editing tools like Magic Editor and Magic Eraser. Every account includes 15 GB of storage shared across Google Drive, Gmail, and Google Photos. When that fills — and for anyone shooting regularly on a modern phone, it fills within months — you pay Google One: 100 GB for $1.99 a month or $19.99 a year, 200 GB for $2.99 a month, and 2 TB for $9.99 a month or $99.99 a year. Google’s October 2026 update added Gemini directly inside the Photos app, so you can now ask its assistant questions about your pictures and get answers drawn from what is in them.

The framing that misleads most people is that Immich is simply the free version of Google Photos. It is not. Immich is a different deal: you trade money and convenience for ownership and privacy, and you take on the job Google does for you — keeping the service running, updated, and backed up. The rest of this comparison is about what that trade actually costs.

Immich vs Google Photos at a glance

Feature Immich Google Photos
Cost $0 for the software — you pay for your own hardware and electricity 15 GB free; then Google One from $1.99/mo (100 GB) to $9.99/mo (2 TB)
Storage limit Unlimited — whatever your own drives hold Plan-based; 15 GB free, then paid tiers up to 30 TB
Automatic phone backup Yes — iOS and Android apps back up in the background Yes — best-in-class, works the moment you have signal
Smart search Yes — CLIP-based semantic search on your own server; type “sunset at the beach” Yes — Gemini-powered Ask Photos understands plain language and follow-up questions
Face recognition Yes — local InsightFace models group faces; you name the people Yes — Face Groups, with face models Google says may count as biometric data in some jurisdictions
Photo editing Basic non-destructive editing: crop, rotate, and adjustments on mobile and web (v3) Advanced — Magic Editor, Magic Eraser, Best Take, Portrait Light; some tools need a Pixel
Video Plays and transcodes on your server; large 4K libraries need real hardware Transcodes everything in the cloud; plays anything, anywhere
Sharing Shared albums, partner sharing, public links; people can now be shared between users (v3.3) Shared albums, partner sharing, family group sharing, public links
Offline access Fully offline on your own network; remote access needs your own VPN or reverse proxy Needs the internet; offline viewing only for downloaded copies
Privacy Your photos and your face data never leave hardware you control Google processes your photos in its cloud; face models are stored by Google
Leaving Your library is a folder of original files — take it and go Google Takeout export, but photos arrive with JSON sidecars and some formats converted
Maintenance You update it, back it up, and fix it when it breaks None — Google runs everything
Best for Self-hosters, privacy-focused households, and large libraries Everyone who wants photo backup to simply work

What it actually costs over three years

The price argument for Immich looks unbeatable until you price the hardware. Start with Google’s side, at US list prices re-verified on November 11, 2026. The free 15 GB is shared with Gmail and Drive, so it is not 15 GB for photos — it is 15 GB for everything. The 100 GB Basic plan costs $19.99 a year, or $59.97 over three years. The 2 TB Google AI Plus plan costs $99.99 a year, or $299.97 over three years. Pay monthly instead and the same three years cost $71.64 and $359.64. A family sharing one plan splits the bill, but the storage is shared too.

Immich’s software costs $0, forever, with no paid tier to upgrade into. The bill is hardware. A fanless Intel N100 mini PC — the usual recommendation for a small Immich box — runs about $120 to $150, idles at roughly 6 to 10 watts, and at US electricity prices that is on the order of $10 to $15 a year to keep running. Add a drive for your library and the honest all-in figure for a starter setup is roughly $200, once, plus about $12 a year in power. Against the 2 TB plan, that breaks even in a little over two years: $299.97 for three years of Google One versus about $224 for three years of Immich hardware and electricity. Against the 100 GB plan, it never pays back quickly — $59.97 for three years of Google One is cheaper than any server you can buy, and it stays cheaper for a decade.

The real cost comparison, then, is not zero against $99.99 a year. It is a one-time hardware purchase and a small electricity bill against a subscription that never ends, with the break-even point sitting at roughly the 2 TB tier. If your library is under 100 GB, Google Photos is cheaper in money and vastly cheaper in time. If your library is several terabytes and growing, Immich wins on money within two to three years — and keeps winning every year after, because the subscription keeps charging and the server does not. The other cost to count is your time: an hour or two to set Immich up, plus occasional updates. At any normal hourly rate, that time alone costs more than a year of the 100 GB plan. Immich is a money-saver only if you enjoy, or at least tolerate, running it.

The hands-on test: what I actually ran in Immich

I signed into Immich’s official demo as its public demo user and spent the session clicking through the real web app, not reading the brochure. The demo runs v3.4.0 — the current stable release, published the day before this test — on a library of 32,948 photos and videos spanning January 2002 to April 2025, which is a fair-sized family archive rather than a toy dataset. Smart search is the headline result: searching for “dog on a beach” returned a full grid of 31 results in the first view, all of them actually dogs on beaches — running, swimming, and playing on sand — including one video, and a second search for “sunset” returned 22 or more warm dusk-toned results. That is local CLIP search doing the job Google Photos does with Gemini, on a server that could be sitting in your house. The People page listed 669 face groups, populated and clustered, though only three were named on the demo (“The 11x Developer”, “The Rabbit”, and “The Gate Keeper”) — the rest waited for someone to add a name, which is exactly how face grouping works before you label anyone. Opening one named person showed 80 photos spanning 2014 to 2025. Albums worked too: 236 of them, grouped by year, and the “City” album rendered 500 photos from 2002 to 2025 with a year scrubber and three people it was shared with. The map view plotted the library on OpenStreetMap with clustered markers — the largest cluster holding 705 photos — and thumbnails at real places from Kuranda in Australia to Marrakesh in Morocco. Two honest blemishes: pages first load as a blank white screen with a spinner for several seconds, thumbnails arrive lazily as grey placeholders, and the sidebar’s server-status indicator flipped intermittently between “Server Online” and “Server Offline” even while everything worked. The demo’s own storage figures also disagreed slightly — 25.5 GiB in the sidebar against 19 GiB in the server stats — a small accounting quirk, not a failure. Uploads were disabled on the demo due to abuse, so I could not test the backup flow itself; that part of the verdict rests on the project’s release notes and independent v3 reviews, as the next paragraph explains.

What the demo test could not tell me matters too. Uploads are disabled on the public demo, so I could not test background backup from a real phone — the feature that decides whether Immich works as a daily driver rather than a photo archive. For that, the honest evidence is the project’s own changelog and independent reviews of v3: the v3.0.0 release rebuilt Android backup around a new periodic task scheduler specifically because the old backup missed photos, and a 10-day review of v3.0.2 reported that mobile backup held up as a daily driver, with search and face recognition close enough to Google’s that the reviewer stopped reaching for Google Photos out of habit. I could also not measure the server’s memory use here, but the v3 review put the full stack at a minimum of 6 GB of RAM with 8 GB recommended — which is why this test ran on the demo instead of this machine. Treat the backup claim as verified by the project’s own release notes and independent testing, not by a phone in my hand.

Search and face recognition: close, but not equal

Search is where Immich comes closest to matching Google, and where the gap is still real. Immich runs CLIP-family models on your server: it turns your photos and your typed phrase into embeddings and matches them, so you can type “sunset at the beach” and get the right pictures without ever tagging them. Face recognition uses InsightFace models, also local: it detects faces, clusters them into people, and you name each person once. The v3.3.0 release improved the machine-learning models further — faster inference, less memory, and new PP-OCRv6 text-recognition models — and you can opt into the optimized model set with a single environment variable. In practice, independent testers find Immich’s search covers roughly 90 percent of what they actually search for, and its face grouping is surprisingly accurate, occasionally needing a manual merge of duplicate clusters.

Google’s search is still better at the edges. Ask Photos, powered by Gemini, understands follow-up questions and odd phrasing — “show me the dog at the beach from 2019” — in a way a local CLIP model does not, and Google’s face grouping handles blurry photos, age changes, and thousands of faces with an accuracy no self-hosted tool matches. Google also keeps adding to it: the October 2026 Gemini integration lets you ask the assistant about your pictures, and an October 2026 app update is expanding Ask Photos into album creation and library insights. The trade is the same as everywhere else in this comparison: Google’s models are better because they run on Google’s infrastructure, on photos Google holds. Immich’s models are slightly weaker because they run on your hardware, on photos that never leave your home. For finding a specific person or a specific kind of scene, Immich is good enough. For conversational, follow-up search, Google is still a generation ahead.

Editing: Google wins, and it is not close

This is the one category where Immich does not really compete. Immich’s editor, rebuilt in v3 to bring mobile editing to the same level as the web editor, does non-destructive crop, rotate, and adjustments — you can revisit or revert an edit later without touching the original file. That is genuinely useful, and it is about where Google Photos was five years ago.

Google Photos’ editor is far ahead. Magic Editor reframes, relights, and restyles photos with generative AI; Magic Eraser removes photobombers and clutter in a few taps; Best Take blends a sequence of group shots so everyone looks their best; Portrait Light fixes bad lighting on faces. Google removed the Google One subscription requirement for Magic Eraser, so it is now available to all Google Photos users, though some devices cap the number of free erases per month. Best Take needs a Pixel 8 or later, and the newest AI assistant features — editing and sharing from a single prompt — are rolling out with the October 2026 Gemini integration, with the fullest version reportedly requiring a Google AI Pro or Ultra subscription. If photo editing is a daily habit rather than an occasional crop, this alone can decide the comparison. Immich has no answer for Magic Editor, and its roadmap does not pretend otherwise.

Sharing and family: both work, Google is smoother

Both services handle the family use case, and Immich has closed most of the gap in v3. Shared albums let other users contribute to or view a collection; partner sharing shares your whole library, or specific albums, with one or more partners; public links share a collection with anyone who has the link, without an account. The v3.3.0 release added shared people management, so you can share a named person with another user in your household and both of you see the same face group, with edits to the name or birth date reflected for both. That is the feature that makes a family library feel like one library instead of two accounts that happen to hold the same photos.

Google’s sharing is smoother in the details. Partner sharing is a two-tap setup, shared albums support comments and activity, and Google’s family group shares the storage plan across up to five other people. The difference is friction, not capability: on Immich, sharing means creating accounts for each family member on your server and explaining how to reach it from outside the house; on Google, it means sending an invite to an email address they already have. The one place Immich wins on sharing is the link itself: a public link to your server never expires into a Google account requirement, and nobody’s access depends on a company staying in business. For a household where everyone is technical, Immich’s sharing is fine. For a household with grandparents, Google’s is the one that actually gets used.

Privacy, ownership, and the exit

Privacy is Immich’s strongest argument, and it is worth stating plainly. With Immich, your photos live on a disk you can physically point at, and the machine learning that indexes them — face embeddings, semantic-search fingerprints — runs on that same hardware. Nothing is sent to a third party, there is no advertising business anywhere in the stack, and the AGPL license means the code itself is auditable. If you run the server on your own local network with no open ports, reachable from outside only through something like Tailscale or WireGuard, your library is never exposed to the internet at all.

Google Photos is the opposite by design. Your photos are stored on Google’s infrastructure, and Google’s face-grouping feature builds face models that Google itself says may be considered biometric data in some jurisdictions. Those models are kept until you delete them or your account sits inactive for more than two years. That is not a scandal — it is how a cloud photo service works — but it is a real difference, and it is the same tradeoff that runs through my Proton Drive vs Google Drive comparison, where the no-tracking model wins on principle but asks more of you.

The exit matters as much as the entrance. With Immich, your library is a folder of original files plus a database — if you leave, you take the originals, unmodified. With Google, you leave through Google Takeout, and the export arrives with JSON sidecar files carrying the metadata instead of embedding it in the photos, and some formats get converted on the way out. That is not a lock-in trick so much as a chore: expect an afternoon of cleanup if you ever migrate a large library off Google Photos. The Feb 2025 lesson from the e-reader world applies here too — when a company controls the download button, it can change what the button does — and my Kindle vs Kobo comparison covers a case where exactly that happened. With Immich, there is no download button to change, because the files are already yours.

The maintenance tax nobody budgets for

This is the section that decides the comparison for most people, and it is the one Immich’s fans understate. Running Immich means you are on call for your photo library. Immich’s own upgrade documentation says, in plain language, to expect breaking changes and bugs between upgrades, and specifically warns against running automated update tools like Watchtower on it without supervision. The v3.0.0 upgrade was a case in point: it shipped breaking API changes and a migration guide, and while the team designed it to be breaking-change-free for most existing users, the release still went through four release candidates before it was declared stable. Immich ships weekly releases, which is a sign of a healthy project and also a sign that staying current is a recurring job.

Then there is the backup problem, which is really two problems. Immich has a database-backup feature that automatically backs up its own database, but that is not a backup of your photos — you still need your own plan for the library itself, and a single drive in a mini PC is not a backup. The honest minimum is the 3-2-1 rule: three copies, two media types, one offsite. A second drive, or an encrypted offsite copy, is part of the real cost of self-hosting, and it is the part most first-time Immich users skip until a drive fails. Google, for all its faults, does this for you: your photos exist in Google’s infrastructure with redundancy you never have to think about, and if your phone is stolen, your library is still there.

The fair way to say it is that Immich does not eliminate the subscription — it converts it into a different kind of payment. Instead of $19.99 or $99.99 a year to Google, you pay with setup time, update time, backup discipline, and the risk that you are the person who has to fix it at 11 p.m. when an upgrade leaves a container restarting. Some people enjoy that. Most people do not, and they should not feel bad about choosing the service that just works. The self-hosting comparison that frames this best on this site is Plex vs Jellyfin, where the same convenience-against-control math decides a media server — and where the honest answer is also that the free option costs an hour of setup and a willingness to maintain it.

The verdict: which photo library should you trust?

Choose Immich if you want your photos on hardware you own, with no subscription, no storage cap, and no company processing your library — and you are comfortable being your own IT department. It is the right choice for self-hosters, privacy-focused households, and anyone whose library is large enough that the two-year break-even against Google One’s 2 TB plan actually matters. Its search and face recognition are genuinely close to Google’s for everyday use, its v3 releases keep closing the gap, and your library is a folder of original files you can take anywhere. Go in with eyes open: budget a mini PC and a drive, set up a real backup, and expect to spend an evening on updates a few times a year.

Choose Google Photos if you want photo backup to simply work — automatic, instant, searchable with plain language, and editable with tools Immich cannot match — and you are comfortable paying for storage and trusting Google with your library. It is the right choice for almost everyone else, and especially for families, where the two-tap sharing and zero maintenance are worth far more than the subscription costs. The 100 GB plan at $19.99 a year is cheaper than any server you can buy, and the 2 TB plan at $99.99 a year is the price of never thinking about photo storage again.

And the honest third option, the one most people should actually take: run both. Keep Google Photos as the daily driver — the backup that works the moment you take a picture, the search that finds anything, the editor that fixes anything — and run Immich as the archive of record, fed by the same photos, on hardware you own. That costs the Google One subscription plus roughly $200 of hardware once, and it buys you the only thing neither service offers alone: a photo library that survives Google changing its prices, and a photo library that survives your server breaking. For a collection that holds your family’s history, that redundancy is the cheapest insurance in this comparison. If you shoot RAW, by the way, both handle it — and my Darktable vs Lightroom comparison covers what to do with those files once they are safely stored.

Frequently asked questions

Is Immich really free?

Yes. Immich is open-source software under the AGPL-3.0 license: the server, the mobile apps, and every feature — including face recognition, smart search, and partner sharing — cost nothing, with no paid tier and no premium features behind a paywall. What you pay for is your own hardware and electricity to run it on.

Can Immich replace Google Photos completely?

For most of the core jobs, yes: automatic mobile backup, face grouping, natural-language search, albums, memories, and sharing all work, and v3 closed much of the remaining gap. Where it still loses is photo editing — Google’s Magic Editor, Magic Eraser, and Best Take have no equivalent in Immich — and convenience: Google needs no setup, no updates, and no backup plan of your own.

How much does it cost to run Immich?

The software is $0. A starter setup — a fanless Intel N100 mini PC at roughly $120 to $150 plus a drive for your library — runs about $200 all-in, with electricity on the order of $10 to $15 a year at 6 to 10 watts idle. Against Google One’s 2 TB plan at $99.99 a year, that breaks even in a little over two years. Against the 100 GB plan at $19.99 a year, Google Photos stays cheaper for a decade.

Does Immich work offline?

Yes, and that is one of its real advantages. Immich runs entirely on your own network, so it works with no internet connection at all. Reaching it from outside your home needs your own remote access — a VPN like Tailscale or WireGuard, or a reverse proxy — which is more setup than Google Photos, where remote access simply works.

Is my data private on Immich?

Your photos and the machine-learning data derived from them — face embeddings and search fingerprints — are processed on your own hardware and never sent to a third party. Immich has no advertising business and no cloud service. On Google Photos, your photos are stored and processed on Google’s infrastructure, and its face models may count as biometric data in some jurisdictions.

What happens to my photos if I stop using Immich?

Nothing bad: your library is a folder of original files on your own disk, plus a database. You take the originals and go — no export step, no format conversion, no sidecar files to untangle. Leaving Google Photos means a Google Takeout export, where photos arrive with JSON sidecars and some formats converted, so expect cleanup time.

Similar Posts